The hidden cost of destructive team behaviour, and what it does to Brain Capital.
What happens to an organisation's Brain Capital when people spend more energy protecting themselves from one another than thinking together?
We invest in leadership development, wellbeing and performance. Yet sometimes the greatest obstacle to human capability isn't a lack of skill or motivation.
It's what is happening between people.
And occasionally, one person's behaviour can change the working environment of an entire team.
When influence has nothing to do with seniority
Organisational charts tell us who holds formal authority. They don't necessarily reveal who shapes conversations, relationships and loyalties.
Sometimes the person with the greatest social influence is a junior colleague.
Confidence and challenging authority are not inherently problematic. But repeated undermining, exclusion, discrediting colleagues or encouraging divisions can create a damaging group dynamic.
People become guarded. Others take sides or withdraw.
And when the leader responsible for addressing the behaviour intervenes, they may find themselves portrayed as the problem.
The person accountable for the team becomes the villain in someone else's story.
What's happening in our brains?
Robin Dunbar's social brain research reminds us that navigating relationships, interpreting intentions and maintaining belonging place considerable demands on cognition.
Todd Heatherton's work on self and self-regulation adds another dimension: social acceptance and evaluation influence how we monitor and adapt our behaviour.
When workplace relationships become unpredictable, attention can shift towards questions such as:
Who can I trust? What happens if I disagree? Will I become the next target?
Emotion matters too.
Kristen Lindquist's research demonstrates that emotional experience involves interacting systems concerned with bodily states, knowledge and context. Antonio Damasio's somatic marker hypothesis offers an influential, though debated, account of how bodily and emotional signals may contribute to decision-making.
Emotion isn't the opposite of judgement. It is part of how we interpret and respond to the world.
When colleagues begin anticipating criticism, exclusion or conflict, they may change their behaviour even without agreeing with the person exerting influence.
And the cognitive consequences matter.
Attention and working memory are limited. The effort involved in monitoring relationships and protecting one's position can compete with the resources needed for creativity, problem-solving and sound judgement.
I describe this as cognitive and emotional friction.
Psychological safety isn't permission to behave badly
Amy Edmondson's work demonstrates why psychological safety matters for team learning and speaking up.
But it doesn't mean avoiding difficult conversations or tolerating harmful behaviour.
Psychosocial risk goes further, encompassing workplace conditions that may damage health, including bullying, sustained conflict and inadequate organisational responses.
When senior leaders or HR fail to investigate credible concerns, the problem can become an organisational failure rather than simply an interpersonal dispute.
And the leader isn't immune. They too may experience the cognitive and emotional consequences of prolonged conflict, particularly when responsibility isn't matched by organisational backing.
You cannot build a high-performing team by asking everyone to become more resilient to behaviour the organisation should be addressing.
Five questions worth asking
Who actually holds influence within this team?
What behaviour is being rewarded, tolerated or ignored?
Are people contributing freely, or protecting themselves from the consequences of speaking up?
What happens when someone raises concerns, including the leader?
What is the cost of inaction in lost thinking, performance, expertise and wellbeing?
These questions move us beyond personality judgements towards behaviour, organisational responsibility and performance.
The hidden depletion of Brain Capital
Brain Capital concerns both the capabilities people bring to work and the brain health and conditions that enable those capabilities to be used.
An organisation can employ highly capable people while creating an environment in which much of that capability remains unavailable.
Not because people have become less intelligent.
But because their attention and emotional resources are directed towards navigating the environment rather than doing the work.
Through BrainShaw® and the Brains@Work™ Diagnostic, I examine four interconnected dimensions: Cognitive Clarity, Emotional Regulation, Social Trust & Safety, and Resilience & Adaptability.
These provide a structured starting point for understanding the conditions influencing human capability, not a substitute for investigating misconduct or managing psychosocial risk.
Before investing in another wellbeing or performance intervention, perhaps we should ask what is happening within the team that prevents capable people from doing their best work.
Because sometimes the problem isn't the people.
It's the conditions in which they're being asked to think.
And changing those conditions is an organisational responsibility.
Soraya Shaw MSc Founder, BrainShaw® The Science of Human Capability® Preparing Human Intelligence for the Next Century